Here’s the money quote from Obama’s July 13 speech:
If you've got a business -- you didn't build that. Somebody else made that happen.
Many have criticized this. I offer a new criticism: the statement focuses on what is seen, and misses what is not seen … not once, but twice!
Let’s call what people do with their businesses “Build That”, and what the government does “Make That Happen”.
What Obama’s statement doesn’t say is that a person can also choose “Don’t Build That”, and that government can choose “Make Something Different Happen”.
There are actually 4 possibilities, and Obama is just talking about one of them:
| | Make That Happen | Make Something Else Happen |
| Build That | 1 | 2 |
| Don’t Build That | 3 | 4 |
Obama’s statement suggests that he sees cell 1.
Yet, even a businessperson who admits there is some merit in Obama’s claim is probably scared of cell 2. They’ve built a business, and perhaps the government did make that happen, but it isn’t at all clear their situation can be improved if the government sets out to make something else happen. The track record of our government just hasn’t been very solid for a couple of generations.
It gets worse in cell 3. If we take Obama’s statement at face value that government policy helped make businesses happen, how on earth do we rectify the behavior of the part of the population who didn’t build anything at all? It’s one thing to give someone help, see them succeed, and ask them to contribute back; it’s quite another to give someone help, have them go blow the cash on hats, and not even think to ask for anything in return.
I do know that Obama gets cell 4: he wants government to do something different to help those who haven’t been able to build anything. Who wouldn’t? Well, maybe someone who’s on the hook to pay for it.
And here’s where the thinking gets really muddy. Obama wants to make those in cell 1 worse off so that his shift to cell 4 turns out better. But what could be better for Obama than a future where more people build businesses that the government helped make happen? In short, his plan is take from cell 1 now to fund cell 4 to make cell 1 bigger off in the future? Huh?
I can’t make this stuff up, so how does Obama? By seeing cells 1 and 4 as the only possibilities. Meanwhile, cells 2 and 3 are always there, but are not seen by Obama.